A Tailor's Doctrine/2009/August
Tailorite Tafsir

A woman’s right

From Iman's blog as Musa the Tailor: a period record, not the house's doctrine. Darja's introduction · where it led

Born back-to-back: four witnesses are a serious matter, but neglect is grounds for divorce.
Born back-to-back: four witnesses are a serious matter, but neglect is grounds for divorce.

The sisters’ circle were discussing the marriage problems of one of their number, a very traditional eastern Muslima. Her husband was living apart from her for the most part on business and, when he did return home, absolutely refused intimacy. This had been their situation for the past three years: she had made several attempts at discussion and reconciliation, but he would always find a way to avoid this. Recently, her misery had been brought to a head when she had found a blond hair on one of his shirts and suspected an affair.

The majority of the sisters recommended divorce. The Tailor’s Uzbek wife concurred: “Dump him. You have made every effort to repair your relationship and are now within your rights by the shariah.”

She continued thus:

But your grounds cannot be adultery in this case, even though you suspect it. They are based purely on his refusal for intimacy: this is the beauty of our shariah. Intimacy is recognized as central to a successful relationship.

Regarding the problems of adultery, recall the verses:

And those who accuse chaste women [of adultery] and then do not produce four witnesses — lash them with eighty lashes and do not accept from them testimony ever after. And those are the defiantly disobedient. Except for those who repent thereafter and reform, for indeed Allah is Forgiving and Merciful. (Qur'an 2:4-5)

I think here I would prefer not to short circuit, but to ride the four circuits of accusation (from water to milk to wine to honey, all the way from the action circuit, to the circuit board, to the factory, to the circuit of circuits itself): and only then would adultery be proven in a court of law. This is only because true infidelity is the inverse of a single Bride -- and must therefore span across the four universes in order to be cast out as a shadow.

It's really serious. Whereas every now and then, everyone falters and messes up in a relationship. The Talmud says Adam and Eve were born back-to-back: and the journey is about rotating ourselves 180 degrees, so we become face to face. It's a difficult journey, fraught with hiccups. But these hiccups usually echo through one circuit, a blip over two, very rarely register at three. And in forgiving this, Allah is truly merciful to us all, Alhumdulilah.

From the sound of things, your husband's actions do not register through all four circuits, so inshallah he is forgiven whatever indiscretions you suspect of him. Nevertheless, from her perspective, all courses of action (including divorce) are permitted. And Allah knows best.

[The sisters raised their hands in supplication at this. And then the Uzbek wife continued her advice:]

That is Mercy we wish upon him, a bastard though he may be, he is still, after all, a Muslim bastard.

But the Mercy extends of course to the main victim here: you, my sister. You are permitted to divorce him now, by the shariah. The shariah of Islam prescribes shorting the circuit when all is misalignment within a relationship. The shariah allows us to continue a straight course after divorce and remarry.

While you do not have grounds for divorce based upon suspicion of adultery, lacking four witnesses, it is established that, if a husband is not paying attention to his wife, divorce is very much permitted within the shariah.

If any woman is neglected by her husband, let her divorce him, there is not shame in this: this is the shariah. Allah will provide her with something better.

[At this, another sister scoffed and said: “This might well be the theory of shariah, but all women know the actual realities of the situation. We know what will happen when our sister goes to the Imam at any masjid in London and demands a divorce.” The Tailor’s wife replied thus:]

You are right, of course. Within the Imaginary realm that we call the 21th century, things are simply horribly messed up for the sisters (and the brothers as well). And active campaigning, care and support is certainly needed -- the compassionate good works we attempt to bring about are obviously the only solution to end the injustice you speak of and that I don’t deny in any form. Their compassion is of course enjoined upon us by God, of course. If God is infinite Love, then we know we must also love as much as our finite bodies can manage. And remember also that there are many people working for women's rights outside our community (even, for example, amongst apostates of Islam) who are also doing sterling work to fix the problems of Islamic marriage (basically through a propaganda war and setting up refuges for victims of Islamic marriage). They get my complete support too -- there are some many dodgy sheikhs in London that let all kinds of dangerous stuff fly: so even atheists and apostates also have their part to play here.

Nevertheless, brutal and awful as 21st century London is, we must not forget that it is still an Imaginary realm. A game of chess that got out of control.

But to follow the sunnah is not to throw the pieces out, but rather to perceive what they truly indicate.

And therefore I say the following, trying my best to keep to the sunnah (which often comes close to gallows humour, so don't blame me for bad taste, but the mode of perception stems from deepest empathy nevertheless, if we know).

You have said that the women know the reality of the situation. And challenged our sister to go to the masjid to request a divorce from the imam.

What is the outcome, outside of the Imaginary?

The women know the Realities. They come to the Imam Mubeen , the clear guide, who never leaves the Masjid, and request a divorce, on the basis of the shariah, for they have been neglected by their husbands.

And the Reality is -- he always grants this divorce. Because the fort is governed by the golden shariah, in all things. The Imam Mubeen is shariah's unfolding, enactment, awakening. Inscribed by the very Pen of God. Thus God restores the dead to life, and writes that which they sent forth. (Qur'an 36:12)

Through the law, may there be resurrection. And through resurrection, may there be law.

The women of the Realities now harmonize with this light, standing sentry at the entrances.

And the Guide never leaves the fort.

Thus the womens' request of the Clear Guide mends broken hearts.

Similar posts · close in meaning

Lashings and the Four Witnesses18 April 2010The weakest state is one that does not implement the shariah for zina, the weakest state is one that cannot produce four witnesses for acts of adultery. Because four …The prophetic voice, madness and the brother of lying6 March 2009The professor and the Builder were driving along the A12 to the eastern shores. It was their intent to spend a day at the beach. They stopped at Newbury Park gas station …Interfaith Marriage in Submission19 April 2010Do not marry unbelieving women, until they believe: A slave woman who believes is better than an unbelieving woman, even though she allures you. Nor marry (your girls) …Aisha’s marriage: a Sufi perspective13 January 2010Narrated 'Ursa: The Prophet wrote the (marriage contract) with 'Aisha while she was six years old and consummated his marriage with her while she was nine years old and …Ramadan Reading: a Few Notes on the Second Juz13 August 2010Note 1: Divine Calibration And thus we have made you a just community that you will be witnesses over the people and the Messenger will be a witness over you. And We did …Woman and Sakina – the parable of Umm Waraqah7 March 2009The people debate the hadith relating to Umm Waraqah. But none of them understand. If they could taste this fruit, their thirst might be quenched for a moment this …