
CONTINUED FROM PART 3.
By now, the Professor had appeared, in the eyes of the Muslims, simply and utterly strange. Nevertheless, he continued on:
As for the child, if the man’s discharge precedes the woman’s discharge, the child attracts the similarity to the man, and if the woman’s discharge precedes the man’s, then the child attracts the similarity to the woman.
Narrated Abu Salama: Um Salaim said, “O Allah’s Apostle! Allah does not refrain from saying the truth! Is it obligatory for a woman to take a bath after she gets nocturnal discharge?” He said, “Yes, if she notices the water.” Um Salama smiled and said, “Does a woman get discharge?” Allah's Apostle said. “Then why does a child resemble (its mother)?” (Sahih Bukhari, The Book of Prophets, 55:545)
Our Real is the sublimated Logos. It is a continuous plane that sustains our journey of differentiation. God’s breath becomes sublimated to form the Real, at which point the journey of differentiation begins. It becomes a dialectic stemming from the tawhid of God’s unity of Love. From love, breathing. From breathing, withdrawal and presence. And from withdrawal and presence, the field of differentiation, the field of the Symbolic, the field of our journey back to Love.
And this is what this question of family resemblance deals with: the relationship between the Real and the Symbolic.
The mother and father possess a threefold resemblance, contained within their singular tawhid: 1) there is a Real mother and father, 2) there are two symbolic functions, and 3) there are two signs of something Real.
This Real mother and father are felt by us, regulate and intrude upon our symbolic journey necessarily in order for us to 1) be happy and free of pathologies and 2) to ascend into illuminated life and afterlife 3) realise these two things by recognizing how we are formed, the nature of our sexual components.
Let’s dim the lights and slow it down.
All symbolic functions serve a purpose within a language game (for example, within the game of hadith telling), which is to illuminate our judgement, so that we can come in contact with the Divine. One way of thinking of this illumination is as a form of transcendence through language (rather than out of language). Another way of comprehending illumination is to call it a physical contact with the Real: an intrusion of the Real. It is appropriate to describe this contact — a genuinely felt effect of the Real — as a resonance.
A resonance in the same way that a tuning fork, when hit, will resonate with a particular note. The fork has the letter “C” engraved upon it, so is a Symbolic “C”. The Real’s intrusion is this act of hitting and resonanting, where the Symbolic “C” sounds itself out as vibrations that hit particles of air, carrying the resonance, so the Real “C” is obtained, physically. Our Symbolic lives are like the fork, we cannot escape it, nor hear the note played. But we can resonate, faithful that a sound of Truth is indeed carried, felt as physical vibration across the Body, though not heard with ears. We can feel resonance as illumination (a song of angels). In this way, we simultaneously obtain a Divine transcendence while remaining purely physical.
The essentially sexual nature of this physical/transcendent paradox is well understood within the romantic verses of various Sufi poets (such as Rumi and Hafiz or ibn Arabi’s The Interpreter of Desires and in metaphysical poetry (of John Donne, for example). To speak of the transcendent Beloved can be to speak, simultaneously, of the Real woman. And through the paradox, itself, the resonance of the paradox ad infinitum, ascendence and contact through the physicality of this sublimated Logos: emergence and descent of Sophia, the Illuminated Bride of Prophecy. The paradox of illumination is climaxes through the movement from east to west.
So the purpose of all symbolic functions is always Divine resonance, and sexualized in relation to Prophecy and to the Bride of Wisdom.
The Mother, Father and Child are symbolic functions, so should fall under the predication of the previous statement. So how precisely do they provide Divine resonance? In the third Prophetic answer, what is the Mother, Father and Child’s relationship to Divinity?
They are the symbolic functions of this resonance itself, and therefore form the functions of regulation over the totality of all other functions. The awareness of any symbolic function’s predication over our life is resonance. And that awareness-as-resonance derives from the Mother and Father. Resonance is nothing more than resemblance within the Child, within us. Intrusion is resonance. It is sexual, because resonance resembles and derives from the primordial sexuality of the father and mother. Intrusion, illumination is resemblance. The Mother and Father are the signs of the resonance: they are human fantasy of the Real resonating -- a self-reflexive fantasy that itself resonates with the Real resonating our fantasy in Truth.
So all functions derive from them. And all functions indicate the Divine. To speak of any symbolic function is to be predicated upon by the Mother and Father and to speak of any function (including, self-reflexively, the Mother and Father) in an illuminated mode is be predicated upon by these functions.
How can this be so? And why a Mother and Father, why not, for example, a single function called “resonance”, “resemblance”, “derivation” or “creation”? It is because resemblance is binary and resonance is physical vibration, requiring particles to move forward and backward. It is because the air of which a vibration resonates is the Breath of God: and its felt property
is binary. It breathes in and out.
Let us go through this step by step, focusing on the hadith itself, because it is currently through the hadith that we can encounter this resonance (immediately, in this garden, upon this page).
Note first that the encounter we describe is a human one. As with all illuminated judgements, it will be physical and ultimately, guided by the Light of Prophecy, one of a personal movement and contact with the Bride of illumination upon the sublimated Logos. It is not by virtue of its complex an immediate encounter with God: though its meditation can yield that most desired, Sublime personal encounter, as a tawhidic comprehension of what is implied -- logically -- by the encounter. There is no polytheism here: the Father and Mother are not God, or even aspects or names of God, because God is indivisible. But the Father and Mother are part of the whole apparatus of our cosmos in reference to the Reality of its regulation by God. They form the Face of God. Understanding them, truly, is to understand our relationship to
Creation — both our own and God’s, and comprehension yields the personal encounter.
The hadith is an illuminated judgement, a Symbolic complex, whose inhabiting constructive proof manages to allow us to encounter the Real through a form of physical resonance — precisely through comprehending the resemblance of our space of signs (the Child, our psychological representation of the Real, including what I am about to say) to the Parents.
The problem is that illumination is always self-contained within the space of the Symbolic, the space of the linguistic. And so, even in the mind of a Prophet, this experience of the Real is something that is spoken, said, represented, perceived. And thus, it is spoken, said, perceived, acted upon via signs. The signs of the Real are particularly privileged. While all signs defer to the Reality of the Other, there are some signs, such as that of the Mother and Father here, that are privileged in that they effectively attempt to denote the Real and its relationship to the Symbolic.
When try to describe how the language is regulated by the Real, when we talk about the Real’s relationship with language (and so with our actual experience of life, as life is signification and signification cannot be escaped), we cannot do it in precision, not in the same way we can precisely lay down the laws of Newtonian Physics. We cannot do it immediately. But we can do it indirectly, through sublime poetry of the Body: when we talk about how the Real regulates our life we will require the sublime use of signs that resonate with the purely corporeal, bodily nature of the Real. Signs like the Father, Mother and Child, for example: archetypes of primal sexuality.
Prophecy’s third answer resonates via this sublime agency into the Rabbi’s subjectivity, in two interrelated ways, a second consisting of the foundational precursory resonance that determines the first.
First, as before, the answer resonates with the deeper aspects of Judaic mystical cosmology, and the Rabbi recognizes this just as any open minded Kabbalist would.
If one knows a little of Judaic mysticism, then the productive pleasure of the mother-father archetype presented in the third answer recalls the concept of Arich Anpin -- the Long Face or Face of God -- a crystallization (partzifim) of God’s undifferentiated Light as it becomes fragmented into signs of our conscious reality.
The idea is that, God first creates the world in an undifferentiated form. In order that man might be formed to love God, this form must yield to differentiation, first into a cloud of breath that then reassembles into individual signs. This is the same principle we have discussed earlier: breath yields the primordial human, the Logos, that is sublimated in order that there be a Northern, differentiated space of Reason to facilitate the Journey South to back to love Love. The nature of this differentiation is breathing. But there is more that can be said, regarding the nature of the primordial human and then our fallen, differentiated relationship to the Divine. In Judaic mysticism, the sublimation, the differentiation of the body consists of “broken shards”, resonances or obscured sparks of the primordial directions of the human geography we have already discussed. But within this differentiated space is also a governing, regulating, creating principle -- the Face of God -- that relates to the psychological reality of the primordial human/child.
This Face of God, the Arich Anpin is itself a generative play on an earlier precursory Biblical name of God, the Arich Apaim (Exodus 34:6) often translated is “slow to anger”, but a closer translation being the long breath. The Face of God is itself of differentiated space -- a psychological crystallization of God’s drawing of long breath, felt by us, resonating into our differentiated creation as the symbolic complex of the Divine creative act. This resonance, in turn, when comprehended, leads us to stand before the ultimate Face of Love.
The Long Face is understood as as the interaction between two complementary dual principles of breath: inhalation and exhalation. These form the the primordial Mother and Father principles, respectively. The primordial child, the created human, has a sexualized body, comprehended in turn via two crystallizations: the Zeir Anpin -- the Small Face -- of Masculinity and the Nukva/Daughter/Bride/Shekhinah of the Feminine. The directions we have mentioned become configured within these two crystallizations of the Masculine Face: the north and south are the left and right hands, Prophecy is its head, the up and down form a dialectic of legs.
The Feminine herself, significantly, the pure receptivity/creativity of the Bride is associated solely with the West.
Of course, to say this much is to repeat a Judaic cosmology and nothing more. To grasp how this cosmology within Prophecy’s response is to grasp a cultural family resemblance between the “new” Islamic mysticism and its parental, precursory Judaic form, to understand an unbroken lineage of Truth and comprehension -- an unbroken resonance with the Real that runs -- procreatively signed, erotically charged -- between the cultures and Books of revelation.
But there is a second, deeper, Real resonance encoded within the hadith: that must come from meditation upon these symbolic components, their mutual and coinductive predication, their ultimately self-reflexive dynamic. This meditation will then become an illuminated physical resonance of our meditation itself as resonance with the Real. (We repeat ourselves: meditation is proof, inhabitation, living experience of the complex.)
Let’s try this now, approximately continuing with a mythopoeic Judaic formulation borrowed from the Issac Luria, but mediated via Freud and Lacan.
How does the Long Face -- the Long Breath -- produce the sexualized child? To speak of breathing requires us to speak of the primordial inner and outer: breath flows from the inner to the outer. This distinction is sexual: for sexuality is nothing but distinction of flow from inner to outer. So breathing is sexual. Let us call the inner the Father and the outer the Mother.
The Father breathes out Love to the Mother, who breathes in Love. But if the Divine is a unity, then the breath must be circular. And so the breath is a bijective dialectic: the Mother breathes back Love to the Father.
Similarly, the Father kisses the Mother actively and the Mother kisses the Father in receipt. Every kiss involves two simultaneous modes: of giving and receiving in Love.
Finally, the Father speaks to the Mother, comforting words of Love. In this case, the Mother listens in silence, because, while kissing and breathing is a two-way bijection, the distinction that underlies speech is one of active words and responsive silence. So the Mother is silence here.
And here is the point of the order of the questions and answers, for the third answer predicates the earlier two via resonance, via resemblance. The first two answers are the child of the third. The function of northern fire and the function of southern water/end of time consumption, is channeled from east to west. And these directions -- this psychic geography of the human journey -- constitute the Child and are comprehended as resonance in relation to the Face of the Creator via the resonance of third answer.
The binary modes of breathing and kissing form the face of the son -- the masculine form of the child -- within the configuration of the cosmic child. The masculine is a composite complex of functions that have, within himself, gender. Within his form, however, are sexual resemblances -- forms and resonances -- to the mother and father’s modes of Real Lovemaking. The Masculine is not fully absolutely masculine, but is governed by different internal genders.
In terms of the psychic geography of the masculine form (depicted again in the figure above), the breathing generates the north and south of the child’s arms. A feminine form of northern judgement derives from the mother’s inhalation, because inhalation forms an absolute Other, a lack, an absence of ultimate desire and, as we have described, this lack is what powers differentiation and signification and logical judgement. Thus the symbolic function of the north is really judgement, because of this resonance of judgement in family resemblance to the mother’s primordial lack, her long breath in inhalation of (fulfilled by) the primordial father’s fullness of exhalation. Our journey in signification, in Time, is one of being formed in Love, to become through Love, to abide at the end in Love. And Love is absolute fullness: the father’s long breath in exhalation.
Now, we have related the first two answers to a double crowning, of fire and water, of logical judgement-in-Time and of adab and control of Love, from a Masculine East to a Feminine Receptive West. The two answers encode a transmission of Prophecy -- of balance -- into a Bride of Light and Truth. We have indicated this balance is unusual to our state: normally Prophecy is not aligned with our Femininity, and so there is no marriage or occasional, partial marriage. When we feel the Truth, when we encounter illumination -- then we encounter a moment of illumination, where the Masculine and Feminine are face-to-face, just as the Mother and Father are always face-to-face in their tawhidic breathing. We fall short of this, however: but it doesn’t mean we should not try.
This marriage is the final point of resemblance, for it mirrors the primordial Creative Long Breath in our own creativity, an ultimate resonance in which the Husband is married and face-to-face with our Feminine receptivity. And this occurs through balance -- through the meditation we attempt right now -- of the husband's male and female sides. When this occurs, we have the primordial lovemaking in resonance with the human subject.
The Bride is the essential term here: the reason why marriage is prescribed in the holy books. She is essential for humanity to realise Truth.
The Daughter herself is separate from the breathing. We might call her many things, but at least she is the source of all experiential Truth. The Feminine nature is one of creativity, of dreaming and of speech.
It is significant that the Face of the Daughter is a separate, absolute Feminine term, in contrast to the Face of the Son, who is a composite of micro-masculinities and femininites.
This is because {\em words} of Love from the Father form the face of the daughter within the configuration of the cosmic child. Her perfect sexuality involves an apparent violation of
the discharge rule, which governs the micro-sexualities of the sides of the Male face. Why?
Because the absolute Daughter must be an absolute Truth of speech. So she emerges from the Father rather than the Mother: because she comes from the words of love whispered by the Father to the Mother in the primal scene.
What does this mean? The daughter -- the absolute Feminine term -- is one of absolute Truth: not the woman as a metaphor for text/speech/perception -- woman is the words of the revelation itself. The Daughter is Holy Scripture.
The Qur’an is a woman.
So the law of discharge is not violated here: she resembles her Father, but is Feminine, not Masculine, in the product of primordial lovemaking, precisely to facilitate the ultimate family resemblance/resonance of our inner psychological/human lovemaking in relation to the Long Breath of the precursory lovemaking. If she were Masculine, we could not find God in words.
To become face-to-face, to attain true consciousness of tawhid in resonance with the Face of Tawhid: this is to be married, this is to have the Light shine down upon your Qur’an.
Absolute Truth exists, within this space of multiplicitous differentiation. And she is a woman, facing east.
So place yourself in the Rabbi’s position, for the hadith has situated and encoded the subject with it, the general reading subject-in-meditation/resonance-with-the-map, encoded as the Rabbi-in-meditation/resonance-with-the map! By providing this answer as Prophecy, the Real resonance, the Real regulation that the Long Face has in relation with the Child, the Rabbi/subject/I realizes himself as the child , he grasps his true nature within the configuration, he grasps the inner sexuality of his components, and the outer sexuality of Prophetic Revelation in relation to his Wife. And he is enlightened. He becomes a man walking on this earth as if in jannah.
At this the Professor concluded his speech. You will need to buy his book, The Tailor’s Doctrine: Logic, Literacy and Love , in order to find out how the Muslims reacted, and what was the consequence of that. Currently available only in the celestial library, it will be released to the general public of water by the end of 2011, inshallah.