A Tailor's Doctrine/2012/January
A post

The role of rupture

Dramatic rupture, at a personal level, sometimes leads to radical change, swaps one way for a completely new paradigm. While obviously an opportunity for rebirth, renewal, recreation -- rupture often achieves change by maintaining identity, rather than obliterating/dispersing it.

Maintaining the semblance of continuity from one node to the next. It's not that the identity is an illusion in this form of transmission: it's that identity, originally an outer garment, becomes positioned as a victim in relation to the threat of rupture, rupture externalized as a trauma and identity internalized as preserved, carried, alongside the transmission of re-creation. And, by this process, becomes something truly significant.

Of course rupture may very well be external in source -- there is usually an external reason for rupture -- but identity is not naturally internalized. It is only through victimhood that identity becomes carried alongside the transmission of re-creation, carried along with the play of Divine creativity, like a leaf on a stream.

Then, by saying "it's the same me/tradition/nation/ship/house/book from one world to the next", our re-creation appears at once conservative, defensive and -- miraculously -- a self fulfilling prophecy.

Because nothing should survive rupture from one world to the next. Nothing of the outer garment. Yet this garment of past identity is preserved, matter rendered pure symbol, like an icon or a reverse hieroglyph (the linguistic sign visually resembles the thing it signifies).

I speculate that I am most comfortable with such a thing at the individual level - but not at the group level.

Similar posts · close in meaning

Accruing injury across the cycles16 October 2012I've been comparing my (Tailorite) belief in reincarnation with some of the world religions. Over the past 4 years or so, I've espoused gilgul (reincarnation) as a …Ramadan Reading: a Few Notes on the Fifth Juz17 August 2010Note 1: Creation from a single soul (from Juz 4) O people! be careful of (your duty to) your Lord, Who created you from a single soul and created its spouse of the same …Careers2 January 2012People think a lot about their careers: often with regret, by the time they reach their 30s and things settle into a particular routine that appears difficult to break. …A Christmas Nasheed: Saba Mahmood, Progressive Islam, Postcolonial Subjectivities and Hajar4 January 2011It was the jummah before Christmas, and Sheikh Yufist (the Imam of the Dangerousnutter-on-Sea masjid) was delivering the guest hutba at Visible College. The Professor …The group1 May 2012There are many spiritual teachers who say things I admire in the first instance, but who then trend toward a position I find difficult to maintain: privileging the group …I know what to do now7 July 2013It's always been a question of signs. And particular signs: he called the archetypes, I corrected and named them symbolic functions. But I should have spoken of what I …