A Tailor's Doctrine/2012/December
A post

Intellectual Sufism revisited

2 years ago I has so much energy to engage with my Islamic, particularly Sufic, detractors. I wrote pages in response to the spam I'd get from the ummah on this site and on social networks.

Often, as in the linked article above, I'd be challenged for being in authentically Sufi: "who's your teacher?", "I've never read this in Rumi", "Lacan wasn't a Sufi", "you're over intellectual, you have no heart, you think but don't feel the Divine".

On the surface, I'd debate with people as I believed I had something to "give" them, that the effort to tease and play with detractors was somehow of service to the religion.

But I'd say the reason I fought so hard - and took criticism so personally - was because it hit home when people would say, you've no right, you bring foreign western ideas and have no legitimate initiation into a recognized Sufic order. Of course I had no initiation into any order and my background is very western: because I was pretending to be something I was not, and suppressing the reality of my DNA, I'd get agitated because their criticism would directly shake up my fictional identity as an Islamic mystic. This resulted in what was, fundamentally, an emotional response on my part.

I was a tightly coiled serpent, that gripped a space so hard it seemed that there was a Sufi there, beneath it, and maybe Satan on the other side. When in fact there was nothing at all within or without, but the serpent, coiled and uncoiling over intervals of 12 years.

Similar posts · close in meaning

Intellectual Sufism?23 January 2011_Question: Your analyses are often muddied beyond repair with intellectual references to psychoanalysts and philosophers like Lacan, Deleuze, Guattari, Foucault and the …Sufi Sheikhs29 June 2012I read the following post on FB just then: The importance of Shaykh sufi master, a mature murshid is not understood well. Sufism is a spiritual jourmey. A mature murshid …The Tradition of the Sufis29 October 2012I came across the following post on Facebook. It summarises some important aspects of how Sufism as a minoritarian embodied tradition relates to Islam. If there's a …Two brothers23 June 2009The Tailor sat at the waystation with some other travellers. “Where are you travelling, friend,” an Egyptian traveller asked him. “Back to London,” he replied. The …My last Ramadan as a Muslim20 July 2011My last Ramadan as a Muslim began with a video we at the Vanguard were commissioned to make for the Fast Not Feast campaign: A video on YouTube …Mastery of the internal and external23 August 2009The Tailor had just finished a rather flowery reading of a narration regarding the death penalty for apostates in Islam . One seeker said: “Okay. So there is a deeper, …