A Tailor's Doctrine/2010/February
Cosmology · Tailorite Tafsir

Open day at the invisible college

The Professor said:

Yesterday was open day at the Invisible College. The way the university undergraduate admissions process works in Great Britain is almost counter-intuitive: at least when compared to the straightforward approach of the Australian system, in which students define their preferences for institution, finish their exams and get a single offer to their highest preference depending on institutions' cut-off grades, which again are dictated by demand and quota. Under the British system, students apply for a place, including in their application a list of their predicted final grades. That is, their application includes within it the anticipated result. An admissions tutor (in the case of our College, me) then makes them an offer, making the decision with respect to a flexible notion of cut-off grade. Grades are flexible in the sense that the tutor must examine each borderline application on a case-by-case basis, taking into account the personal background and experience of each potential student, making for a very personal approach, but a massive administration load for me. The number of offers to be made is also only predicted, based on an anticipation of how many students are likely to take up an offer. And this is where open day comes in, because the best students are likely to receive several offers from rival institutions -- they are completely free to select which of these offers they will take up. We (and our competitors) therefore run a post-offer open day, where we try to sell the advantages of studying at our school to students and their parents.

There is another professor who usually speaks at this event: but he recently received a job offer at a rival college (Godless College London). And so at short notice it became my job to give a speech during our post-offer open day, to convince this bright cohort that the Invisible College should be their final choice.

Now, I had some ambiguous feelings about this. Invisible College, like all universities at the moment, has a number of ... let's call them administrative and funding difficulties at the higher level. Generally she is internationally respected in research, but the research quality of our Science faculty has been thrown into doubt by the last government audit. Science's weak output has been blamed on tarnishing the generally excellent research quality of the place. This has resulted in a difficult atmosphere and a lot of uncertainty with respect to the structural stability of the science faculty in particular. I am unsure to date exactly what form science research at the Invisible College is likely to take now: instead, I generally keep my head down and continue running my own little research group (which is, by the Grace, doing ok).

Nevertheless, I still believe in the overall quality of our undergraduate programme -- at least, I believe we produce excellent graduates. So my argument on open day was sincerely meant and, I think, not bad. The summary was as follows:

  1. Our programme has a strong emphasis on the logical foundations of computing: the pure mathematics that defines exactly what a function is, prior to even considering how to programme it. The former polytechs do not cover this material, preferring to immediately jump into Microsoft or SAP languages, teaching students almost from first week how to develop the kinds of applications businesses require. While it might not immediately be clear why such foundational material will be of practical benefit in industry, the point is that computing is still an engineering discipline. Just as engineers have a mathematics that allows them to build bridges that are guaranteed not collapse, computer scientists should also have such a mathematics. Being the youngest of sciences, it has some way to go for this mathematics to be generally understood by all industry practitioners -- instead it is largely the province of researchers like myself -- nevertheless, we teach this at the Invisible College, with the ambition that eventually the mathematics will be more widespread, just as it has become in more established antecedent engineering disciplines. This will ultimately have a real benefit for our information society: imagine a world where an operating system failure on a home computer is as uncommon as a bridge collapsing!
  2. Of course, all the elite universities in the UK provide a similar foundational training. However, we are also unusual in two ways. First, we have a heavy emphasis on artificial intelligence, from the start of the course. The question of constructing autonomous computer systems: not so much as to replace human beings, but rather to enhance our own lives. It is unusual to "jump into" AI so early, but we've found a way to introduce the concepts. Second, thanks to my own particular research interests, we deliver modules on what might be called meta- programming: the question of writing code that itself writes code. Systems that produce other systems. It's a fascinating and useful paradigm that, I believe, will change the way we do computing in the long term (imagine the science fiction scenario of a child wanting to learn the alphabet, and a parent asking a program to automatically write __ a bespoke program that is specifically tailored to the particular child's educational needs, instead of going out to the shops and purchasing one of these generic educational software packages). Because I run the only group doing this type of research in Britain (for some reason, all the focus is either in industrial R&D firms or European universities), we are the only university in this country able to offer this material.
  3. The Invisible College is located the heart of the city. This makes it a great place to work and play. There are numerous nightclubs and bars located in the south and west, if that's your scene. In fact, the College union itself has a fantastic bar located on the third floor of our original building. And immediately to the north and east are the financial and media heartlands, a proximity that we exploit in our industrial engagement, both in research collaboration and in the student internships (which are typical for the very best of our second years).

Yesterday, the Professor finished his sales pitch and opened to questions from the somewhat overwhelmed faces of parents and children (curious, he momentarily observed, to be standing at this sea of family resemblance, each teenager a nervous, tentative variation upon a theme anticipated in the older visage of their mother or father).

One question in particular struck a chord. One applicant asked: "Do you teach hardware at all?"

The professor: "Er ... no, we only get to the level of assembly code, the languages that reside on microchips, not the hardware detail of how microchips are built." (Difficult question, as the department dealing with such issues had been recently wiped from the College's institutional memory. Where was the Builder when you needed him?)

Another student asked: "Do I need to know how to program before starting the course? Because my high school didn't offer computing as an A level."

"No, we've structured the course so that a student need not have any programming experience. We actually begin with a completely different programming language, higher-order typed lambda calculus, which puts everyone on a level footing so to speak, because it's still largely untaught."

Generally the vibe from the applicants seemed quite positive, although, from the professor's perspective, it was impossible to anticipate at this moment how the open days at the rival institutions were being conducted. He had been somewhat aggressive in his comparisons ... What would they then be saying about their benefits over the IC?

"Any other questions? No? Well, I hope I've brought across the merits of choosing Invisible College: don't hesitate to contact me by phone if you have any further questions. I hope to see you all again here in seven months time!"

Similar posts · close in meaning

Death of the Professor17 May 2011'They can't get inside you,' Uma had said. But they could get inside you. 'What happens to you in this College is forever,' the Dean had said. That was a true word. …Biunivocalisation and faciality14 April 2010Once, when still an beardless youth of 12, the Tailor was driven by his mother from their bushland house to Open Day at the gleaming new complex of the Southern …Advice to young scientists4 August 2013As students, you are theoreticians, learning how to make theories that ground engineering. You may have heard people question "the relevance" of your research domain, …Dogs, Cats, Deejays and Journos1 August 2010The Professor was answering an email interview ... 1. Tell me about dogs you've owned- which breeds etc Back in Australia I’ve had 3 dogs. Two, Rover and Dip, were …Communication links24 February 2011Hey fellow space cadets, this is your friendly neighbourhood T. here, with a couple of methodology/experiential notes I thought I might share with you: - Think that the …Scene from a Tailorite Training Centre in the year 301016 March 2010The year is 3010AD. Verandah Vanguard theological training centre, London. Principal Farinelly, standing in front of some pretty damn sleepy first years, sighs and …