A Tailor's Doctrine/2011/August
Tailorite Tafsir

The Commander and Torah

Umar had two interesting relationships with Torah.

There is a weak hadith (from Al-Bazzaar on the authority of Jaabir) that goes like this:

Umar copied part of the Torah in Arabic, brought it to the Prophet , and began to read it to him. As he read, the Prophet’s face changed. One of the men of the Ansaar said, "Woe to you Ibn Al-Khattaab! Can you not see the face of the Messenger of Allaah?’ Thereupon, the Prophet said, ‘Do not ask the People of the Book about anything for they will not guide you when they have gone astray. You will either disbelieve in what is right or believe in what is false. By Allah, if Moses had been alive today, he would have been obliged to follow me.'

There is a (non-Tailorite) Sufic understanding that says Muhammed is not saying "Islam's the best practice" here -- but, rather, prescribing Umar to follow one discipline in order to progress, not to "mix-and-match" in an ecumenical or new age kind of fashion. This is why there are some Sufi sheikhs (won't mention any names) who have been known to get quite irate when if a disciple consults with another sheikh. It's almost like they seem jealous of other teachers -- but, their disciples will assure you, it's not that at all, it's because they care for their students.

It's not so much that they are denying the validity of different paths to God -- it's that, in the view of these sheikhs, a true Sufi must be disciplined to one of these paths in a devoted and serious way, in order to get anywhere. The analogy is like an athlete -- you won't get to the Olympics if you practice a bit of every Olympic sport (short distance, marathon, highjump, discuss) -- you'll win "gold" only if you dedicate your body and spirit to the one sport.

I have heard there are similar points made about martial arts (though haven't verified this myself).

The Tailorite begs to differ: because we are not about tribal practice. Don't get me wrong. We respect the rights of those who practice sports and martial arts -- we respect indigenous culture, the student-teacher subjectivities, the discipline of bayah embodied by the traditional Sufis. But that's just not how we roll.

We don't read Qur'an without Torah. There's a strong dependency between the two (if you want to know how a woman is going to look when she ages, look to her mother), and we are in a new age where we can easily access both -- not only that, but earlier, censored Gnostic works are also freely available, offering further essential lineage.

Umar is forbidden Torah for one reason alone, which is that he always represents the Commanding Self -- whether he's brawling like his precursor Gilgamesh-Enkidu with the idolaters in the City (continuously at Kaba, with breaks to pray only), hitting his sons or beating the daughter of Prophecy due to desire to claim her inheritance -- he's an aspect of the house of Muhammed that is this aspect of the nafs. That means he's a part of you, and a part of me (this is why we don't condemn him, we need to ensure he remains in balance, does not run amok amongst the family of Prophecy, which also exists as part of your face).

This aspect of your selfhood is not permitted access to Torah.

Why? Because its death is predicted within Torah. It cannot therefore look at Torah, it cannot read Torah: it's not permitted because it's an impossibility.

Umar had a Jewish convert Ka'b as his helper/soothsayer, who fortold his assassination:

Ka’b: Amir al-Muminin ["Commander of the Faithful"], you ought to write your will because you will die in three days.

Umar : How do you know that ?

Ka’b : I found it in the Book of God, the Torah.

Umar : By God do you find Umar Ibn al-Khattab in the Torah?

Ka’b : By God, no. But I found your description in the Torah and your time is coming to an end.

Umar : But I do not feel any pain or sickness

On the following day Ka’b came to Umar and said: Amir al-Mu’minin, one day has passed and you have only two more days.

The following day Ka’b came to him and said : Amir al-Mu’minin, two days have gone and you have only one day and one night remaining.

The following morning Abu Lulu appeared carrying a dagger with two heads and a handle in the middle. He hit Umar six times, one of them hit the Caliph in the navel, killing him.
(Tarikh al-Tabari, History of the Prophets and Kings).

Quite correct: Umar, the 7th self -- the Commander Self -- expires with the 7th blow. And this is indeed predicted in Torah: but in reverse. Each of these blows is an Edomite King, but reversed.

What of the Prophet's face changing? When they ask Umar: "Can't you see the Prophet's face?" The answer is: of course, he cannot see Prophecy's face. This aspect of "you" cannot see "your" (Muhammedean countenance), being a component, not a whole. Torah is a mirror to that countenance: hence, again, this is why he cannot read Torah, he cannot see Prophecy's face in that reflection, being a component of the face, not a whole.

What of the Prophet's advice? "Do not ask the People of the Book about anything for they will not guide you when they have gone astray. You will either disbelieve in what is right or believe in what is false." Umar, the Commander Self, is attached to carrier mechanisms -- people of the book -- because that is a structure over which he can command -- and, of course, the Commander will never have guidance from his carriers -- quite the opposite, he'll have (Pharonic) command, inability to tell right from wrong because the power structure that facilitates that command (the carrier structure) will become the criterion, rather than the Criterion (Qur'an).

"Musa would follow me": this is not about loyalty to one teacher. This is a tafsir on the laws of marriage. It is forbidden to marry the wife of one's father, because that would be a blockage of transmission, from Musa to Muhammed (that is, the circuit of the cosmic body, from Musa, the left foot, to Muhammed, the crown of the body). The Commander reverses the circuit (and hence expires), Qu'ran corrects the circuit.

Similar posts · close in meaning

Mastery of the internal and external23 August 2009The Tailor had just finished a rather flowery reading of a narration regarding the death penalty for apostates in Islam . One seeker said: “Okay. So there is a deeper, …Ramadan Reading: a Few Notes on the Ninth Juz24 August 2010**Note 1: Al-Araf ** The seventh surah is named Al-Araf (heights or places of elevation) after the description of the afterlife, in which the companions of the garden …Ramadan Reading: a Few Notes on the Twenty-First Juz29 August 2011Note 1: Pharoah Indeed, Pharaoh exalted himself in the land and made its people into factions, oppressing a group among them, slaughtering their sons and keeping their …Aisha’s marriage: a Sufi perspective13 January 2010Narrated 'Ursa: The Prophet wrote the (marriage contract) with 'Aisha while she was six years old and consummated his marriage with her while she was nine years old and …Borscht westerns, polygamy, matriarchy in Sumatra, temporary marriages ... and Islamic flirtation: the Tailor and postcolonialism20 July 2010The Tailor: The Soviet propaganda machine produced a "Borscht Western" called "White Son of the Desert". It was very popular in its day. It functions as entertaining …Scene from a Tailorite Training Centre in the year 301016 March 2010The year is 3010AD. Verandah Vanguard theological training centre, London. Principal Farinelly, standing in front of some pretty damn sleepy first years, sighs and …

2 comments · as on the original

James Souttar 8 August 2011, 15:46

"Umar is forbidden Torah for one reason alone, which is that he always represents the Commanding Self... That means he’s a part of you, and a part of me (this is why we don’t condemn him, we need to ensure he remains in balance, does not run amok amongst the family of Prophecy, which also exists as part of your face)."

Something seems vaguely familiar about all this... ;-)

One aspect of the genius of the Prophet is that he recognised that Islam needed the uncompromising energy of Umar. He alone could open Jerusalem (and, of course, the story of Umar entering the holy city astride a donkey shows that, in his own way, he understood what it meant to be humble before God).

Much as I incline towards the party of 'Ali, and the ahl al bayt , I sense that 'Ali did not possess this understanding of human nature: he held people to a sometimes impossibly high standard. Muhammad could align people's individual natures with the propagation of his message, even if those natures were hypocritical or harsh or venal. This is a Sufi science, but one which not all the Sufis have possessed to an equal degree.

Where a person is under the direction of a master of this science, there can be no 'different paths to God'. A lesser teacher would have had to 'undo' Umar - to give him practices to wear away these harsh and fierce qualities. But the Prophet could point him in a certain direction where his qualities became positives - towards his own particular 'private face in God' (al wajh al khass), the qiblah of his own personal Lord. But had Umar left the path the Prophet laid out for him, he would have reverted to being a force of destruction.

tailorofthegoodgarmentthe Tailor 8 August 2011, 17:21

Peace James,

Right - you reminded me of this Hadith - but while you obviously don't take it this way, I've heard it recounted a number of times by traditionalist Sufi types - as an argument for not reading Torah (an argument directed at me, knowing that I often draw on Torah).

I completely agree with everything you wrote - assuming you are talking about the/a fictional Umar/human. The fictional Umar is a component of the soul, like Bima to Ardjuna ... Thats why he's essential, entering the fictional Jerusalem. I couldn't accept this if it were literally true! It's very important to recognise it as a literary truth under the iqra perrogative - if we get literalist we'd believe Sufis were actually capable/willing to manipulate humans like this ... Which would be politics rather than math ... No?