A Tailor's Doctrine/2012/July
A post

Q & A

Tailorite Disciple: What is that shahada about? What is God? How to make namaz to this tree of life, to the sefirot of moving conduits?

The Tailor: I'm not a Muslim so can't comment legitimately -- I learnt about shahada and namaz from internet sites less than a decade ago.

In the past I tried to integrate Islamic signs with the particular trip I was on -- with my own throwness, my own life. So I used to argue with Muslims that namaz itself was the tree of life, joints of the skeleton in motion etc embodying the various conduits of Light's transmission etc: that salat is the proof of God, being unfolding. I read that similar concepts appear in Judaism -- but again I only surmise that through internet auto-didacticism.

I had also argued that the shahada's meaning was that Allah = Love and Muhammed = you (the reciter), and slave/messenger = bestowal/giving, you breathing in/out in mirror of the Allah/Oneness.

Muslims would react angrily to what I was saying: because Muhammed isn't "you" in traditional Islam -- he's a real person. So the argument falls apart -- the signs are the same but the life of my proof (that I attempted to force to inhabit the signs) was genetically insincere with respect to Islam (my deviant proof desired their proofs, not their theorems/signs).

But as a Muslim who is also a friend of Tailorism, you could try to run with something like that -- but they are your inherited totems, so you must work to achieve something that comes naturally, not what comes artificially. Of course it's easy to adopt what I am saying as the "meaning" of your shahada, of your namaz and so on. But I'm not talking about meaning -- not an equation of "God = X". I'm talking about a life-force/proof that naturally inhabits the signage, like flesh beneath a well tailored suit. If what I say doesn't fit the signs you have been given, if the signs don't naturally emerge as a product of the life-force I'm exchanging/offering here -- if this is not a compatible axiom system, then it would be an artificial proof, a failed proof.

I am not comfortable with reciting shahada myself: it isn't a natural thing for me as I wasn't taught it by a teacher or a parent -- I learnt about it from the internet. And so, speaking as a foreigner, it seems like a great record of an important person's life, a record/trace of a particular man's relationship to God. This man's relationship to God/Truth has some similarities to mine, but others that I cannot identify with. I can identify with his documenting a relationship to God -- but not with his formation of a group/nation/culture to recite and carry the trace of that personal relationship. I'd rather people form their own traces, not carry those of other people -- no matter how charismatic/exemplary that trace is. I'd say that the shahada is one man's own personal trip (a power trip) -- and a demonstration of how particularly strong wills can shape entire sections of humanity. He's a great thought leader, like a Gates or Jobs, able to influence large armies to declare his particular relationship with the Guy in the Sky Who Runs the Whole Show and to redirect the possibility of their having a relationship through his particular imagined theocratic-metaphysical-sign regime.

But books and other people's traces are not sublime, at best only an echo of sublimity: it's life, your life alone, your unique trace that can be truly amazing.

Similar posts · close in meaning

A Q/R Mapping14 October 2012Q: Qaf. By the honored Qur'an... R: 10x10 (Sarah's end, the 10 micro sephirot within the 10 macro sephirot). An oath (a right sided flow of gnosis enacted) through …Ramadan Reading: Iqra peanut butter sandwiches!9 August 2011Q: I am concerned at the complexity of your Ramadan Reading commentary on the Qur'an. It's quite impenetrable at times -- much more so than the very Book it attempts to …The Tailor unclothed: the prophetic voice, madness and the brother of lying revisited4 March 2012It's about three years since I posted the following characterisation of the Prophetic voice , a position I spent some time expounding, within this blog and within the …Reading and Niyat24 March 2011A sister from Norway asked the Tailor: "You have stated here that you would continue with your Tailorite Sufic reading of the Sahih Bukhari even if it turned out that …The test12 June 2012People talk about life being a test. Islam is one of the religions that speaks of a God who put us in this world to test us . If we are to think of it this way, what is …Ill communication24 December 2012I wound down the Tailor's Doctrine, as it was originally defined, two years ago: as a resource that was meant to communicate a precisely defined view of Islam to …