A Tailor's Doctrine/2013/October
A post

Civilisation and the temple

I read recently in a popular science magazine about a reevaluation of how religious systems relate to the origins of sedentary agrarian civilisation.

Traditionally, the thought has been that environmental changes (like the ice age) meant food sources became more scarce and hunter-gathering was necessarily replaced by organised agriculture. This changed how we lived and led to larger social states and modes of coordination and control: social law, kingship and temple based religious order were consequently scaled up from primitive, small scale nomadic modes to the "civilised" modes that have operated up to this day.

A challenge to this theory has been brought about by the discovery of sophisticated religious ruins that appear to predate the transition to agriculture.

Some prehistorians speculate that the origins are the other way round: organised religion was the catalyst for agrarian/sedentary civilisation, not a byproduct or means to sustain it. They imagine tribal belief systems becoming more elaborate and religious organisation scaling across tribes. Larger temples were constructed requiring cooperation between still nomadic groups, delivered by some caste of designated holy labourers. Labourers were perhaps full time - and so food supplies were delivered to these labourers by the civilian hunter gatherers. Perhaps seeds of these supplies left near the temples germinated and led to the idea of agriculture: an accidental byproduct of the need to organise temple construction.

It's a cute theory, but entirely speculative and kind of wooly even when treated as such.

There is one point I like behind the rethinking: that agrarian sedentary civilisation is an entirely contingent, primordially capitalist power structure, not evolved of necessity, but appearing instantly, the moment humans saw food as capital, as symbolic, as evaluative signification within social grammar of consumption and production. At that moment, the spectre of the civilised god appears as a crystallising fetish of capital itself: the sexual face of the marketplace in essence.

When we dreamed production of food, we spoke a new and powerful language of exchange, and so we dreamed, simultaneously, God, the ecstatic divine, the unnamable eternal surplus of production.

One didn't really occur as a byproduct of the other: they are the same thing.

Even the anti materialist Divinity of Christ and the Buddha is still really a sadomasochistic permutation of this Diety of production: renouncing consumption is still to privilege it within your sexual ontology - just like celibacy is still a sexual orientation.

The bigger question, beyond anthropology, is where do we go from here?

I like the Roman approach to religion and civilisation, which was very open about the Deity as a fetish of different aspect of social/productive grammars. It's something we lost as we entered into the Christian transcendent.

The Islamic civilising project also blurs the line between Deity and diet, the grammar of production and consumption -- and their ultimate holy fetish, the one true God. But it is inauthentic with respect to the reality of this fetish - and rather the fetish takes over and doesn't recognise the grammar as real - there's no fetish but the fetish.

Simplistic folk superstition believes in a super-material order - I can pray to a jinn for more money etc - but this is not a real fetish, not the elite religion of civilisation.

We're really talking about recognising and controlling the psychic-sexual-spiritual will to fetish that surrounds our grammar of production.

Similar posts · close in meaning

They/you/hate/love10 October 2013Civilisation is like an intimate crevice, a golden paradigm of the cave man Prophet. Adam, the first man: perfect or base, the twin positions. Is, the goddess, the …The Tailor unclothed: the prophetic voice, madness and the brother of lying revisited4 March 2012It's about three years since I posted the following characterisation of the Prophetic voice , a position I spent some time expounding, within this blog and within the …Death and the internet intellectual (the Tailor slums it on youtube)12 November 2012I'm really slumming it with a critique of -- yeugh -- an internet secularist intellectual. I really ought to be doing better things with my brain. (I've seen things you …Ritual and religion2 May 2012I would like to say that piety/ritual is physical (and therefore unethical) in primacy and contrast to religion. Religion (and ethics) derive from desire for the …Sex and difference3 September 2012"A woman who wore a tight niqab was up for it," says an Egyptian boy, justifying his views on the legitimacy of certain kinds of sexual harassment . Sexuality is a great …Ritual6 October 2015What motivates men to ritual? There's the participant in the ritual, the initiate who embodies the ritual, who lives and breathes it, who's body is marked, constrained, …