A Tailor's Doctrine/2012/February
A post

Why I'm the Qutub of this Time

Because, irrespective of who I am, how
much I know or my own personal rank, what I have is so appalling to the people of the book, so antithetical to their current preoccupation/occupation that, to embrace me would mean instant fana. Instant fana for the lot of them.

And this understanding is unconscious within them, they listen and nod - but eventually, when they realize the implication and threat to their a selfhood and identity, they become angry: each and every one of them.

Their response is always the same: "practice what you preach"/"speak for yourself"/"do it to Julia - not me, Julia!"

Then there are people who understand everything I say, who embrace me: but their embrace is not fana, it's either intimacy or not. But either way, their embrace is not fana for them.

And therein lies the paradox of my position: he who is angered by what I say, I am his salvation, and I've written a key for him. I write his book. And he who is enamored with my words, who grasps what I say without resistance, I have no key to provide for him -- I don't write his book.

Similar posts · close in meaning

Modesty, spouses and slave-girls: a moral compass13 June 2010In Hebrew and Arabic, yamin/yemen means both south and right, while semol/shemaa l means both north and left. This anthropic coincidence with the points of the compass …A teacher's story: how water was crowned by fire2 March 2009"Homework for next week. Compare and contrast the following quotes." The professor handed out the assignment. “I am the One whom I love, and the One whom I love is …Who are the hypocrites?24 September 2012I've noticed a trend in more Sufi-oriented social media towards religious condemnation of the ummah's reaction to the YouTube short, "Innocence of the Muslims". …The Sunnah: Revisited4 April 2012Three years ago I wrote this piece on my understanding of the Islamic sunnah. My understanding was that, though the language game -- the cultural vocabulary -- of the …Thank you!18 December 2010It has been two years to the day that I began peddling my wares here at the Doctrine. 167 entries, 366 comments and 43,623 views (and a few public engagements, dubious …Ramadan Reading: Iqra peanut butter sandwiches!9 August 2011Q: I am concerned at the complexity of your Ramadan Reading commentary on the Qur'an. It's quite impenetrable at times -- much more so than the very Book it attempts to …

3 comments · as on the original

This sounds a lot like Hegelian dialecticism. Can progress only be found through opposition?