A Tailor's Doctrine/2012/April
A post

The Sunnah: Revisited

Three years ago I wrote this piece on my understanding of the Islamic sunnah. My understanding was that, though the language game -- the cultural vocabulary -- of the Prophet is different from the language games (cultural vocabularies) that have followed -- his "path", his sunnah is constant. I identified this path with a particular mode of perception, a kind of phenomenology, wherein God's true message is revealed as a self-referential transcendental intimation embedded within the very matter of component signs' configuration. Thus the truth of the woman you love is in her embodiment of the sakina, the feminine presence of God. Thus the "truth" behind buying a bottle of milk -- is the intimation of the river of milk, the second heaven of malakut -- the realm of gnosis above language gamed. the model above the objects, reflecting the invariant truth across the games into which it self-refers as a symbol of milk.

What's wrong with the piece? Its repressed motivation. It privileges its sunnah's perennial perceptive comportment over disconnected, culturally and historically situated "games". Why? Because it is written by a man who is culturally and historically disconnected, whose individual physical/genetic identity is a ruptured set of "games" -- he only plays at being a believer, plays at being a Muslim -- or rather, his belief is a symptom of his physical desire for a physical body. He has externalized this fragmented dislocation, forming the image of one culture disjoint from another.

He discounts the physical lineage (the bodily inheritance) of one Muslim to the next, across the ages -- in favour of a fetishized perennialism. Because that is what my perennial sunnah consists of: it appears timeless, eternal self-reference to gnosis unfolding. But in reality, it is narcissistic: my sunnah is a self-reference/ourobus machine, whose capital/fetish/perversion is built upon an unspoken desire for the bodily inheritance it denies and whose unholy spirit is, in fact, the ghost of my own dislocated knowledge-base, the constituent, cut-and-paste technologies of my tafsir.

It is worth examining my perennial phenomenology under the microscope: it involves a particular trick that is deliberately absurd. That is to say, it often begins with an outward appearance of disconnection of contemporary language game (buying milk) from the culture of the past (the Prophet's) but, in order to locate its eternal truth, a Semitic root is still required, but rendered as a transcendental archetype. So a particular, unique language game (Tailorite Tafsir) is still required to read things "right". The trick is that, invariably, the transcendental archetype actually self-refers to its position in this paradoxical play of perennial sunnah versus cultural context ("milk" is culturally situated but its Semitic transcendental archetype refers to cultural situation -- and to transcendence of culture).

This rather tangled way of reading continues to appeal to me.

Nevertheless: the ghost in the machine is my own knowledge base, the connections, the cuts and pastes I have made through my own (always autodidatic, largely web-based) research. Of course, drunkedness also contributes (but let's leave that aside for the moment). For example, the relationship between the river of milk and the heaven of malakut is a connection I made, and quickly fixated upon, after a random web search, in visionary synchronization with a reading of a particular Qur'anic translation: I believe the equation of milk with malakut is my own invention. It would be madness to claim that this invention is universal -- it is the product of a culturally dislocated, disembodied person.

There's no universal perception here -- no Prophetic style of perceiving truth within the signs' own self reference -- instead there's a close loop language game -- an loop machine I've constructed from my own knowledge, my own cut-and-paste body. And this game is perverse: because its capitalism, its fetish, its ecstasy and pleasure -- derive from denying (via loops) the lineage I desired -- denying the cultural and genetic inheritance of the actual Muslim race, the bodily habitus they carry, in succession back to the body of their own Prophet (whether he existed or not, it doesn't matter, it's still genetic inheritance). Thus my perverse former sunnah kills the father of a race and places my own eye/my fetish in his place: essentially an Oedipal transposition of a fatherland-less Tailor.

Similar posts · close in meaning

The Sunnah4 April 2009And the goal of religious practice - specifically, the purpose of following the sunnah (way) of the Prophet (peace and blessings) is to recover as much light as we can, …The Tailor unclothed: the prophetic voice, madness and the brother of lying revisited4 March 2012It's about three years since I posted the following characterisation of the Prophetic voice , a position I spent some time expounding, within this blog and within the …Of body and tribe, fetish and gnosis18 March 2012O you who have believed, avoid much assumption. Indeed, some assumption is sin. And do not spy or backbite each other. Would one of you like to eat the flesh of his …Prayer and the Body: Revisited7 April 2012Two years have passed since I penned this piece on prayer and the body. In it, I argued for what I was experiencing at the time: that the Logos is a higher order entity, …Of blood, shit and symbolism19 March 2012The reason why the Tailorite objects so vehemently to literal interpretation of the Qur'an and Torah (circumcision, genocide, warfare, menstruation, wife beating, etc) …Hagarism and Scriptural Neurosis2 April 2012Holland's new biography of the Prophet offers an origin of Islam based on non-religious contemporary sources, framed within the rules of academic speculative history. It …