A Tailor's Doctrine/2012/March
A post

Reversion and the body

Chapter 6 of the Doctrine offers a schizo-analytic subversion of the Islamic saying: "You have returned from the lesser jihad to the greater jihad". My subversion consisted of:

  • Maintaining a hyperliteralist stance: departing from the traditional reading, taking the "greater jihad" as a metaphoric battle for the soul, or the "lesser jihad" as a physical battle in which actual bodies are killed, I said both jihads involve deaths and bodies, but re-defined what these terms mean in their Reality, in terms of what really exists, underlies it all.
  • I said a (lesser) death is a transformation between what underlies it all -- regimes of signs -- a transformation from one regime to another. War consists of speech acts that shift paradigms. This is not a metaphor: there is nothing other than regimes of signs to kill -- there is no such thing as a "physical body" in the sense we think of it, there are only forms of identity generated within political, religious, biological, sexual, social loci (regimes).
  • I said that a (greater) death is bodily, is physical, not symbolic. But that it involves a body, the Real body, that is unknown to most. The body of Christ -- but re-read as Deleuze and Guattari's body without organs -- or Merleau-Ponty's flesh -- the actual fabric of the universe itself, upon which regimes of signs/identities are temporarily encamped, transformed, re-established. A pure surface, productive, energized -- not semantic, possessing no deeper inner meaning (organs) -- ecstatic skin and hijab of the universe.

What I produced was a marvelous schizo-analytic re-reading of jihad, one that, in the mode of schizo-analysis, presents itself like a factory, offering an Islam of infinite, unbounded creativity. If jihad is breaking down and transforming and recreating paradigms (of your own life, of the orders within which you reside) -- then jihad is life and life is pure, unabated creativity. And if the actual body is without organs, without an underlying, if the real body is pure surface -- then the universe/Christ (and hijab) is knowable and always present (not deferred) through relative valuations, pure relativity, through your creative re-incarnation.

When I released Muslims wouldn't accept this view, I fell into a state of depression. Which is peculiar, as the view is sufficiently obscure and wild as to render acceptance a remote prospect.

The main reason is sexual: I think I fell into a situation where, rather than properly "reverting" (converting) to Islam as a religion, I sublimated my sexual, physical attraction to Muslims (and to a select number of particular Muslims) with this particular comportment toward their religion. The nature of this sexual attraction is reasonably complicated -- and specific to myself, my own history (mixed race, not knowing the "Islamic" component of my ancestry, the nature of my relationship to my father, etc).

But when I think about how I first approached Islam, it was through wearing the clothing of Muslims -- embodying a Muslim identity, physically -- not even a Salafi Muslim, but an ethnic Muslim. I wore kufi, but not robes, a moustache rather than a beard, for example, looking more like the "ethnic" Turkish Muslims of Melbourne than a Salafi. The photographs from that time make us laugh -- because of the absurdity of that role-play. But, up until now, I didn't give much thought to why I'd enter into it -- apart from dismissing a "dress up" phase as typical of most reverts/converts. This experience -- of identifying my body with an ethnic Muslim (physical) body -- is a sexual identification, first and foremost.

And when I think about how I evolved my approach toward Islam, coming to the point of cultivating a unique, influencing voice of my own: I'd say that, all the while, this sexual identification continued, through infatuation with/the fetishizing of particular men and women, by reflecting my own (physical, bodily) identity as a Muslim through the attention of Muslims.

I'd say it intensified, because there were actual individuals involved rather than a blanket ummah -- intensification witnessed by virtue of the (philosophical, creative) complexity of its sublimation.

Fundamentally, underlying my schizo analytic position regarding the true body without organs -- there is my physical body, speaking out of physical fetishization for other Muslim bodies, sublimating (psycho-analytic) desire through schizo-analysis.

And so, when I finally lost my friendships with these particular individuals, I found myself in a state of despair.

I didn't fully recognize the psycho-genetic motive behind my writing. That's not to say I didn't recognize it at moments -- I comprehended parts of the sexual motive as an immanent ambivalence, a Tantric play of physical/metaphysical love. But I only recognize the Tatra where it was aligned to my schizo-analysis, the belief that desire (creativity) is not sublimated, not driven by underlying repression but is, rather, an immanent force.

I would have said it is sexual, but sexuality in terms of pure energy surface play over the real body.

I am now obliged to recognize that my saying that -- is motivated by desire for something , a sexual identification with/over-valuation of Muslim bodies underwritten by personal, unresolved physical/genetic identity issues that exist under the surface of my body, and manifest as Chapters 6 and 7 of the Doctrine, psychoanalytic causes to my schizoanalytic position. The body has organs.

Similar posts · close in meaning

Prayer and the Body: Revisited7 April 2012Two years have passed since I penned this piece on prayer and the body. In it, I argued for what I was experiencing at the time: that the Logos is a higher order entity, …Umm Waraqah and the Judaic Interruption21 March 2012Three years ago, I published some notes on the hadith of Umm Waraqah . The brief commentary was an opening into a revision of Islamic tafsir - through a cousin …War and bodies17 March 2012Another perspective on what I wrote regarding the spiritual subject and war as symbolic action . What I failed to acknowledge there was that there is also a religious …The Tailor unclothed: the prophetic voice, madness and the brother of lying revisited4 March 2012It's about three years since I posted the following characterisation of the Prophetic voice , a position I spent some time expounding, within this blog and within the …Hagarism and Scriptural Neurosis2 April 2012Holland's new biography of the Prophet offers an origin of Islam based on non-religious contemporary sources, framed within the rules of academic speculative history. It …The Mi'raj revisited19 June 2012So successful has been my disconnect with Islam (!) that I forgot it was the Muslim anniversary of the Mi'raj and Isra over the weekend, until a Facebook post reminded …