A Tailor's Doctrine/2012/April
A post

Hagarism and Scriptural Neurosis

Holland's new biography of the Prophet offers an origin of Islam based on non-religious contemporary sources, framed within the rules of academic speculative history. It is the kind of approach that is anathema to most Muslims and, as such, got me thinking about Hagarism again. Hagarism's narrative is similar in trajectory, though more creative and blasphemous: suggesting the Qur'an itself is assembled from a collection of earlier texts, redacted to cover up an original spiritual-political allegiance between the Jews and Arab proto-Muslims (Hagarenes), whose focus was on the recovery of Jerusalem (the creative aspect is in the hypothesis that Umar was the Jewish Messiah, reconstructing the Temple). Once Jerusalem had been conquered, it became apparent that a stronger break with Judaism was needed, in order to solidify the power of an Empire after the style of the displaced Byzantium, one faith united by one book -- and so the need to rapidly redact what was a heterogeneity of spiritual texts into a uniform scripture. This event happening some 150 years after the original allegiance -- a long time in the ancient world, rendering the repressive crystallization at least plausible.

I'm not able to speak about the reality of such speculative history: whether things happened this way or along the traditional account.

I am more interested in speaking about the relationship between psychology (mine) and the possibility of such speculation: the threat of Hagarism as a reflection (or deferral) of my own scriptural neurosis.

In the past, I've claimed to be uninterested in whether Muhammed "really" did such-and-such (fought in the battle of Badr, claimed flies can cure diseases, etc). Because within the schizo world of Tailorite Tafsir, it is the scripture itself (Qur'an and the wider field of sira and hadeeth) that is the true reality -- the underlying historical accounts -- the science of archeology and so on -- that is the illusion. I'd go further and reconcile apparent contradictions within the texts, apparently jarring abrogations of laws and divergent siras, Shia and Sunni, utilizing a "parallel universe" reading of this underlying textual reality, where several Prophets could co-exist simultaneously.

I'd deny that this means the scripture is to be taken metaphorically: to the contrary, it is daily, material life that is metaphoric, while scripture is the actuality, the essence of reality. The holy letters of the Qur'an themselves are the atoms of this reality, the archetypes of Prophet, his family, the events of his life, these are encountered by us as symbolic functions that govern the ways in which we configure signs to make up the metaphoric illusion of daily life. We encounter God by studying the archetypes, identifying where they align to events of daily life, aligning signs in such a way as to induce Divine transmissive flow across the composition of these functions: this is what I called following the sunnah of the Prophet. And why a studied reading of his life, from the traditional sources, was important to me.

But I believe there was something deeper, running below the surface of my denial of the importance of historical reality. If the Prophet didn't exist in a recognizable form, if the Qur'an itself is a redaction motivated by political need: of course this would matter to me.

Why would it matter? Of course I had accepted that the Qur'an is Divine word, but I also accepted it was Divinity filtered into the vocabulary of a 7th century Arab merchant, utilizing a very specific, historically dated mystical language game. It is Divine word, and the final word, but manifested within a particular, specific context. Does it matter if the Divine word also unfolded into reality differently, via the agency of a later redaction? It's still Divine word.

Still, it matters. It mattered to me that Muhammed, the (historically situated) revelation was pure text -- whose true origin is beyond speculation -- rather like the late Pope John Paul, addressing a group of astrophysicists at a conference on science and religion, accepting the big bang theory, permitted them to study the cosmos after the creation, but not to investigate the first moment of that big bang, as sacrosanct. And speculation such as Hagarism -- as well as literal, traditional accounts -- are a threat to that textual Tailorism.

Why would it matter ... to me? I wasn't born into Islam, I threw myself into it, motivated by particular psycho-sexual/genetic desires I've noted in recent posts. It's not my religion to defend. I don't have the cultural/racial attachment to take offense and start burning effigies -- it's not as though I could really suffer my Muslim inheritance being insulted, as I never knew any of my Muslim ancestors. And yet, within the pages of my Doctrine, I exhibit a barely suppressed emotional reaction to the threat of historical reevaluation, the threat of history itself.

And here we get to the essence of the matter. I've previously said that the "pure text", schizo reading of scripture -- is a fetishization of my own deferral of desire to possess a Muslim body, a Muslim genetic identity. I felt delight in that reading because my own predicament (sexual/genetic desire for physical identity, repressed) was rendered a second order fetish (the object of desire is replaced with deferral of the object, deferral being an endless play of metonymic reading/tafsir).

What is the historical threat here then?

  1. All historical biographies of the Prophet are a reminder of the original object: lineage, genetic lines of authentic identity back to a definitive womb. The ties of kinship, as the Qur'an puts it. I desire to possess a bodily identity, my desire is, first and foremost, a sexual desire to reclaim/revert to that tie of kinship.
  2. A biography that denies the Prophet -- that lineage to an origin is illusion -- therefore resonates with my own illusory lineage -- the fictitious Islamic identity I have constructed for myself (an identikit of wikipedia searches and translations of Qur'ans). The denial of his authenticity is threatening -- not because it is a stand in accusation/denial of my own authenticity as a Muslim, a proxy reminder of the repressed anxiety of my own self re-creation.
  3. A biography that supports the Prophet's origin -- the traditional sira -- also resonates with me, emotionally -- because, if Islam has a real, physical, bodily origin -- and the culture/religion/race of Islam is therefore rooted in lineage, a direct, father-to-son chain of transmission from a man to the people of today -- then that is something I do not have. Again, therefore, such a biography is a stand in reminder/denial of my desire for authenticity.
  4. Only my intermediate, fetishized state of continual reading/pleasure of tafsir can satiate (always momentarily) my desire for physical authenticity/a tie of kinship, by means continual play and innovation.
  5. Thus, historical biography is simultaneously a proxy for the object of my desire (genetic/racial/cultural/sexual authenticity) and also a severance /denial of that desire's schizo-perversion, the second order fetishization of desire. (Muslims would often repeat the same phrase -- "Stop it" -- to me when reading my work or listening to my speeches -- this key phrase was always taken emotionally by me, because, coming from the lips of a genetic Muslim, the phrase is a stand in for the same proxy desire/severance of pleasure) It's no longer exciting/arousing the make tafsir now that we all acknowledge the possibility the Prophet was X, Y or Z. Now that we acknowledge lineage is what is at stake here, it's no longer arousing. "Now that I acknowledge it's 'just' a naked woman underneath -- that it was sex with her that I wanted -- the capital of whip and leather is lost on us and, ironically, I cease to become aroused."

The situation becomes more complicated when we examine individual speculative assertions made within a text like Hagarism. The political motive, in particular -- the capital gain effected from the redaction of a uniform text and faith -- this resonates as proxy for my own capitalism of deferral, fetishized tafsir and the false presentation of a uniform reading/cultural authority upon which to operate this caliphate of the fetish.

Those who are born into the discursive tradition of Islam will have a radically different relationship to Hagarism and Prophetic biography. Where there is a threat, it is a colonial one -- an act of cultural violence/incursion upon their sacred territory.

To me, not born into that tradition, the threat is purely psychosexual, played out within the theatre of someone else's dreams.

Similar posts · close in meaning

Of blood, shit and symbolism19 March 2012The reason why the Tailorite objects so vehemently to literal interpretation of the Qur'an and Torah (circumcision, genocide, warfare, menstruation, wife beating, etc) …The Tailor unclothed: the prophetic voice, madness and the brother of lying revisited4 March 2012It's about three years since I posted the following characterisation of the Prophetic voice , a position I spent some time expounding, within this blog and within the …Umm Waraqah and the Judaic Interruption21 March 2012Three years ago, I published some notes on the hadith of Umm Waraqah . The brief commentary was an opening into a revision of Islamic tafsir - through a cousin …Reversion and the body12 March 2012Chapter 6 of the Doctrine offers a schizo-analytic subversion of the Islamic saying: "You have returned from the lesser jihad to the greater jihad". My subversion …Prayer and the Body: Revisited7 April 2012Two years have passed since I penned this piece on prayer and the body. In it, I argued for what I was experiencing at the time: that the Logos is a higher order entity, …The Mi'raj revisited19 June 2012So successful has been my disconnect with Islam (!) that I forgot it was the Muslim anniversary of the Mi'raj and Isra over the weekend, until a Facebook post reminded …