A Tailor's Doctrine/2012/March
A post

Becoming religious: the conditions of conversion

Is it possible to truly convert to another religion? Religious identity, like racial identity, is fundamentally physical -- the religious subject is a physical body, first and foremost -- revelatory scripture is intimate with biology.

There are implications. For example. Religious discrimination is a kind of racism, a discrimination against bodies. It's no coincidence that forms of Islamophobia tend to focus on the body (beards, clothing, diet): not because these are secondary aspects of an objectionable medieval belief system but, rather, these are components of a physical embodied subjectivity -- the Muslim body -- that antagonists object to. Islamophobia is not about beliefs -- it is about bodies. Quite correctly, too: because Islam is not a belief, it is a genetics, group of bodies, embodied practices.

Religion isn't solely racial -- it possesses scripture, text, symbolic capital. Scripture is intimate with the religious body from the moment it passes through the lips of the reciter: the religious body is a bio-symbolic complex, not hardware and software as Cartesian yin/yang, but, rather, functions or machines, occupying the same ontological status , the symbolic production machine employed to embed itself within the workings of the biological engine, to titillate and excite, condition and constrain the physical body.

This complicates the possibility of conversion.

Speaking for myself, I never converted to a religion -- because I failed to meet the racial criteria. Islamophobia is racism -- which means that conversion to Islam is conversion to a race, not just to a belief system. Is it possible to "become" Greek, if you do not possess Greek DNA? Is it possible to truly become a woman by means of transgender operation? I reserve judgement. While I failed at becoming Muslim physically, we see other cases, where the epitome of a particular race is often migrant stock (e.g., Stephen Fry or Helen Mirren as the epitome of Englishness) -- somehow a full becoming, an entry into an indigenous tribal habitus has been effective, authentic, convincing -- rather than mere simulacra in imitation.

Perhaps one condition for effective (or ideal) racial transformation must be solving your own physical hang ups -- so your entry into taking on a new religious body (a sexual entry) is not "complicated" by fetishization nor by the fetishization of your own body, reflected/known by taking on the Other. On the one hand, you cannot become effectively if you overthink matters -- if the symbolic/revelatory machine itself becomes fetishized over the body that it interlocks with. On the other hand, a lot can go on unconsciously -- if you identify your (current) body with a religious body (mirroring) -- you can fetishize that identification, this fetish itself becoming the means to excite and arouse you, in your current racial condition -- ultimately meaning a full racial transformation (conversion) is never even attempted. I'd say I'm guilty of on both counts here (my current condition being displacement, my fetishizing the Other appears as a becoming Other but is, rather, an erotic identification of myself in the Other -- there's no change to my body, only forms of desire that are momentarily satiated by viewing the religious Other in particular ways, dress-up routines).

Similar posts · close in meaning

Personal explanations3 January 2012There's always a personal explanation for why people convert to a religion -- a personal explanation, not a spiritual explanation. And most people you find these days -- …Reversion and the body12 March 2012Chapter 6 of the Doctrine offers a schizo-analytic subversion of the Islamic saying: "You have returned from the lesser jihad to the greater jihad". My subversion …Why I'm not a Muslim26 June 2012You'd think it's because I didn't get on with fundamentalists or something like that. Actually it was because my fundamentalism -- my colonial universalism -- proved …Violence and religious distinction15 September 2012Violence is integral to all dualities. A duality is grounded on a repressed desire to self harm, the death drive. When the decent members of a religion see their …Prayer and the Body: Revisited7 April 2012Two years have passed since I penned this piece on prayer and the body. In it, I argued for what I was experiencing at the time: that the Logos is a higher order entity, …The Religion of the Cyborg1 October 2012Recent media coverage of #MuslimRage highlights an important point about Islam in particular, and religion in general. Muslims burning houses over a Facebook picture …