A Tailor's Doctrine/2012/June
The path

Why I'm not a Muslim

You'd think it's because I didn't get on with fundamentalists or something like that. Actually it was because my fundamentalism -- my colonial universalism -- proved incompatible with the embodied, cultural specificity of Islam.

It's put very well in this article:

While they differ over the character of their preferred "reformist Islam", both Manji and the Islamists she castigates are on shared ground in assuming that the trouble lies in one interpretation of Islam and that the solution lies in another. But in fact the problem lies in framing this as a discussion about Islam as a religion to begin with, as happens in the never-ending debates about the compatibility of Islam with liberalism, democracy, or free speech. Such a framing puts the burden on a minority to prove its compatibility with the prejudices of a majority. This perpetuates the tendency, among both Muslims and non-Muslims, to think of Muslims as Muslims first and alone, rather than treating their concerns as those of any other citizen, for whom religion is one marker among many, including class and ethnicity.

Religion is one marker among many, including class and ethnicity. This is a profound statement to make, given the pretensions of religious scripture. Islamophobia, therefore, is a reality -- it occupies the same status as racism and class war.

For me to be a Muslim, I had to believe in the epistemic impossibility of Islamophobia. Which clearly isn't sustainable -- because clearly there are specific identity markers in place -- and, as I've reflected often here recently -- the Tailor (my westernized "mystical Muslim identity") was the fetishization of these markers of identity (fetishization so as to make specific identity a diffuse universal).

Similar posts · close in meaning

"True Islam" revisited10 November 2012I was in a rather confused state when I penned this piece on "True Islam" . I'd kind of already given up the fight, by that stage, but was still going through the …My last Ramadan as a Muslim20 July 2011My last Ramadan as a Muslim began with a video we at the Vanguard were commissioned to make for the Fast Not Feast campaign: A video on YouTube …Hagarism and Scriptural Neurosis2 April 2012Holland's new biography of the Prophet offers an origin of Islam based on non-religious contemporary sources, framed within the rules of academic speculative history. It …Muslims in the West9 December 2009The crypto-Nazis and general racist bigots say: Islam is a virus that, if unchecked, will overcome our native laws, government and culture, supplanting them with an …Prayer and the Body: Revisited7 April 2012Two years have passed since I penned this piece on prayer and the body. In it, I argued for what I was experiencing at the time: that the Logos is a higher order entity, …Who are the hypocrites?24 September 2012I've noticed a trend in more Sufi-oriented social media towards religious condemnation of the ummah's reaction to the YouTube short, "Innocence of the Muslims". …

1 comment · as on the original

Barbara Flaherty 27 June 2012, 05:37

I'm listening. Sometimes now, not always, when you write you get close to truth about self and the world, and it is pleasing to hear someone do that. This is one of those times.