A Tailor's Doctrine/2013/July
A post

degeneration

when a situation degenerates, it's a terrible thing. there's not a supernatural reason for an entire group's descent into savagery. it's a question of organization and control: a sociological, economic and political dynamic equation that has failed to balance.

we look at degeneration often through a photographic lens of some kind. and so the following may sound harsh, but it's not meant to be: assistance is a religious idealism, and assistance itself, even the most seemingly humanist, is grounded upon 1) the concept of a transcendental "punishment" from on high and 2) a consequent transcendental redemption or forgiveness, within 3) a schema of fate, pre-destiny, karma.

this is an error. there's no such thing as assistance. it's an ontological impossibility, a transcendental fetish. but there are (eventually) seasons of recovery, natural seasons, purely economic and political trends, rebalancing the system.

can we do a rain dance, to bring about the rain after drought? it wouldn't hurt. but ultimately you -- the intellect -- have a right to feel frustrated when rain doesn't come so quickly, because there isn't a transcendence here, there is no such thing as fate, no punishment nor redemption, things simply didn't have to be like this: the equation was faulty and parties involved failed to balance it.

and someone -- the leaders -- are correctly blamed here, though not in a religious or even moral sense, but in a purely economic sense.

http://www.theatlantic.com/infocus/2013/07/afghanistan-in-the-1950s-and-60s/100544/

Similar posts · close in meaning

ethnographic notes from kazakhstan25 August 2013i've been coming here for more than 10 years now, but it was only during this visit that i fully understood how a particular post-colonial anxiety towards language and …Responsibility24 July 2013The leaders have a responsibility. This is not a moral statement but, rather, an acknowledgment that the social power of the term "leader" is based upon the privilege …Borscht westerns, polygamy, matriarchy in Sumatra, temporary marriages ... and Islamic flirtation: the Tailor and postcolonialism20 July 2010The Tailor: The Soviet propaganda machine produced a "Borscht Western" called "White Son of the Desert". It was very popular in its day. It functions as entertaining …Civilisation and the temple14 October 2013I read recently in a popular science magazine about a reevaluation of how religious systems relate to the origins of sedentary agrarian civilisation. Traditionally, the …The Tailor unclothed: the prophetic voice, madness and the brother of lying revisited4 March 2012It's about three years since I posted the following characterisation of the Prophetic voice , a position I spent some time expounding, within this blog and within the …Help5 August 2012And though you authored help And though you denied fear ... ("The Brothers", The Friends of Design) What is the nature of "spiritual assistance", spiritual help? It …