A Tailor's Doctrine/2012/March
A post

What's wrong with Deleuze and Guattari?

I've had a go at D&G's ideas a number of times on this site and within the Doctrine -- occasionally cutting-and-pasting, often reacting to, certainly abusing or subverting:

  • Incorporeal transformation was central to my groundbreaking reevaluation of jihad within my former religion: that the "lesser jihad" is a kind of speech act that transforms, while the "greater jihad" is truly bodily, but over a "body without organs", not a body in the normal sense of biology. This is argued within Chapter 6 of the Doctrine.
  • I took their notion of sign regimes, lines of flight and characterisation of the nomad versus the city and, drawing on their own readings of Moses and Muhammed in A Thousand Plateaus, re-read the nature of Medina, Mecca, hijrah.
  • I subverted/abused their notion of faceology, linking it to Kabbalic concepts of the Face/Head of God, triangulating the Qur'anic "Face of Allah".

So what's wrong with Deleuze and Guattari?

It's that, underlying their work, is the Anti-Oedipus: the denial of sublimation's role in the origin of meaning. The belief (a schizo position, as they call it) that desire is purely productive, pure metonymy, a factory and means to production that is shackled by philosophers, bankers, psychoanalysts, armed with imaginary complexes (Oedipal), falsifying the claim that sublimation as a reason for desire's existence. They deny that desire is desire for the unobtainable -- rather, it is raw energy, capital. They free desire from the family (mother-father-child), and interface it immediately with society: applying hyper-Marxism to liberate the desire from familial control (from the control of absence/presence/desiring subject).

The schizo position is great in principle -- and I think is one that genuinely underlies religious revelation.

But, coming to think of it, everyone I've met who reads and admires D&G (including myself) is an incurable neurotic, not a schizo. Who's got something to hide, repressed, something kept out of view, some hidden motive that drives their need to read and admire D&G.

There's an underlying reason why the schizo position is held up in high esteem by the neurotic. Fundamentally, it comes down to their biological need, biological trauma that is unresolved and unaddressed.It comes down to desire in the face of absence. The schizo position is a rant, a rave, a religious incantation, a mystical hysteria, a fantasy dhikr.

Ditto for other schizo authors (need not mention names here), presenting visions of schizo lifestyles, schizo wars, schizo revelation.

Similar posts · close in meaning

Ramadan, Tourism and the Freudian Theatre of Desire13 July 2010The Consumers’ Association of Penang recently raised some concern at a statement made by the Malaysian Minister for Tourism Datuk Seri Dr. Ng Yen Yen regarding Ramadan. …Reversion and the body12 March 2012Chapter 6 of the Doctrine offers a schizo-analytic subversion of the Islamic saying: "You have returned from the lesser jihad to the greater jihad". My subversion …The spiritual schizo21 March 2012The spiritual schizo exists within a shimmering, ecstatic, intoxicated, timeless frenzy. All possibilities are open, all is infinite, generative potential: for pleasure …The lover’s gift, inscriptions upon the body and individual returns3 March 2009The professor and the builder were visiting a gallery. They went to see a controversial retrospective of a Somalian born Dutch national artist called Ayaan van de Paddo. …Hagarism and Scriptural Neurosis2 April 2012Holland's new biography of the Prophet offers an origin of Islam based on non-religious contemporary sources, framed within the rules of academic speculative history. It …The Tailor unclothed: the prophetic voice, madness and the brother of lying revisited4 March 2012It's about three years since I posted the following characterisation of the Prophetic voice , a position I spent some time expounding, within this blog and within the …